Who Is Missing from Our Churches?

Disability, Belonging, and the Chinese Church

•

Looking through a glass church window to a courtyard with a family with a special needs member. The family looks as if they are fading from the view.

Photo-illustration by Andrea Lee

My Introduction to the Difficulty of Disability

When I was a teenager, I occasionally accompanied my father on pastoral visits. My father has served as a pastor in Chinese-speaking churches for more than three decades, and these visits provided opportunities for me to meet people and learn about ministry.

One particular visit really stood out to me because it introduced me to the complex and difficult world of disability.

We were visiting a retired Chinese pastor, someone who was highly respected. He is what you might call a typical elder statesman within the Christian community. As we sat together talking in this pastor’s living room, I began to hear crying and wailing coming from somewhere downstairs.

What struck me was that nobody even remotely paused to acknowledge it. The conversation just continued as though nothing was happening.

I was only sixteen or seventeen years old at the time, so I said nothing. But as we walked back to the car, I asked my father whether he had heard the sounds. Perhaps it was the neighbors or the television in the next room? It just felt odd that no one even flinched, and the dismissiveness almost felt rehearsed.

Dad explained that the pastor has a son with an intellectual disability. His existence was something of an open secret. People knew about him, but he was rarely seen outside the family home. Few spoke about him, and some did not even know his name.

I remember feeling really stunned about that because here was a family that had dedicated much of its life to serving the church. Yet there seemed to be a shocking silence and shame surrounding one of its members.

Of course, I do not know the family’s full circumstances. Caring for someone with significant disabilities can involve considerable challenges, and it would be unfair to assume that I understood their experience from a single encounter. Furthermore, families have the right to choose how public they are about their children’s disability, especially if it is for their safety and protection.

Nevertheless, that experience really stuck with me. If the church is meant to be a community of love and belonging, why did disability seem so difficult to talk about? The question simmered and stewed in my mind.

When Disability Became Personal

Years later, that question would take on an entirely new significance. I became a pastor myself. I also became the father of a daughter with a disability. As a result of these experiences, questions about disability were brought in from the distance because they had become woven into the fabric of my family life.

As a father, I began to think more deeply about the kind of world my daughter would grow up in. As a pastor, I began to consider the kind of church she would belong to. And as a theologian, I found myself asking whether our understanding of the Christian faith had sufficiently accounted for the experiences of people with a disability.

These questions eventually led me to undertake doctoral research in disability theology and Christian mission.

For those unfamiliar with it, disability theology is a field of Christian theological reflection that takes the experiences and perspectives of people with disabilities seriously. It invites us to reconsider how we understand God, humanity, the church, and Christian discipleship.

At first, this might sound like a specialized subject that is relevant primarily to people with disabilities, their families, and those involved in disability ministry.

However, I have increasingly come to believe that disability theology is relevant to the whole church because it helps us recognize truths about the Christian life that we might otherwise overlook.

What Disability Teaches Us About the Church

Consider how we usually understand a healthy church.

We often celebrate churches with gifted leaders, effective ministries, energetic volunteers, and growing congregations. We value people who can serve, organize, teach, lead, and contribute.

To be sure, none of these things is wrong. Churches need faithful leadership, and the willingness of Christians to use their gifts in service of others is something worth celebrating.

Yet this deficiency is accompanied by a profound danger. For example, when effectiveness and productivity become our main measures of success, we may inadvertently begin to value people according to what they can contribute. When that happens, what do we do and how do we think about someone who cannot participate in the ways we ordinarily expect?

What about a person who cannot communicate verbally? Someone who requires significant physical assistance? Someone who finds large gatherings overwhelming? Or someone whose disability makes consistent participation in organized church activities difficult? How about someone who might struggle to understand and articulate the basics of the Christian faith? Are these individuals still recognized as members of the church?

The apostle Paul offers a striking answer in 1 Corinthians 12. Describing the church as the body of Christ, he insists that those members who appear weaker are actually “indispensable” (verse 22).

This is a remarkable statement because here Paul challenges the assumption that certain members are less necessary because of their apparent limitations. He wants the Corinthians to recognize the value of those whom they might otherwise overlook or regard as less important based on cultural expectations. I believe most Christians understand this conceptually. However, the implications are rarely applied to bodies and minds that experience impairment.

This is one of the central insights of disability theology, for it tangibly reminds us that our identity and dignity are not determined by our abilities, achievements, or independence. Rather, they are grounded in the God who created us and calls us into relationship with himself and one another.

Indeed, dependence is part of being human! We enter the world dependent upon others. Throughout our lives, we depend upon families, friends, communities, and countless people whose contributions we rarely notice. Above all, as Christians, we depend entirely upon God’s grace.

I find this particularly helpful because careful theological reflection shows us that disability can make certain forms of dependence more visible. But it does not make dependence unique to people with disability. If anything, it helps us to realize that perhaps the problem within our churches is that we have confused Christian maturity with self-sufficiency, when the gospel actually teaches us to receive life as a gift.

Why This Matters for Chinese Churches

These reflections have particular significance for Chinese Christian communities.

Across diverse Chinese cultural contexts, themes like family relationships, intergenerational responsibility, mutual obligation, and communal belonging have often played important roles in shaping Christian life.

These can be tremendous strengths. In contrast to cultural ideals that celebrate radical independence, Chinese churches often understand that individuals are embedded within networks of relationships. We belong to families and communities that carry responsibilities towards one another.

I believe these instincts provide a valuable foundation for responding to disability. Yet they can also reveal a crushing contradiction.

In communities that highly value family honor, achievement, and social contribution, disability may sometimes become associated with shame, inadequacy, or the fear of burdening others. Families may experience pressure to conceal their difficulties. People with disabilities may be welcomed as recipients of charity without being wanted as full participants in Christian community.

Of course, these challenges are neither universal among Chinese churches nor unique to Chinese culture. I can think of several Chinese Christians who have demonstrated extraordinary generosity and commitment in supporting people with disabilities.

But there is an important distinction between caring for someone and recognizing that they belong. Consider a church that generously supports a family affected by disability yet rarely considers how they might participate in congregational life. Or a congregation that faithfully prays for a child with a disability but has made little effort to get to know that child. Even our best-intentioned ministry programs can overlook the experiences and perspectives of the very people we hope to serve. These examples should prompt us to examine whether our commitment to caring for people has translated into genuine relationships and shared belonging.

This is where disability theology can help us. I believe Chinese churches already possess many of the cultural resources needed to cultivate communities of belonging. The challenge is to extend these commitments to people with disabilities, especially when their participation requires us to rethink our usual practices and expectations.

Disability theology is like a stress test for our churches. It forces us to consider whether our understanding of belonging is truly grounded in the gospel or whether it remains conditional upon certain expectations of ability, independence, and contribution.

Our Belonging Is Itself a Witness

One thinker who has shaped my research is Lesslie Newbigin, a missionary and theologian who spent many years serving in India.

Newbigin argued that the church itself plays a vital role in making the gospel visible to the world. The Christian message is communicated through preaching and teaching, but also through the shared life of a community shaped by Jesus Christ.

He famously described the church as the “hermeneutic of the gospel,” which means that people should be able to look at the church and begin to understand something of the good news we proclaim.

I believe that disability theology helps us take this conviction more seriously. Imagine a church where people are valued regardless of their productivity. Where dependence is neither embarrassing nor shameful. Where families affected by disability are supported and people with disabilities are heard, honored, and recognized as members of Christ’s body. Such a community would offer a powerful witness to a world that frequently measures human worth through success, efficiency, independence, and achievement!

Importantly, people with disabilities do not need to demonstrate their usefulness to the church in order to justify their belonging. Their dignity is not conditional upon what they can offer. Nevertheless, their presence, perspectives, gifts, and participation can enrich the church in ways that it might never otherwise experience.

This is the movement I hope to encourage: one in which we move from charity to belonging, and from belonging to a deeper understanding of Christian witness. For indeed, Newbigin highlights that the church’s mission is not just something accomplished by its most capable and eloquent members, but is something embodied by the whole community as we learn to live together in dependence upon Christ.

An Invitation to Pray Together

When I think back to that pastoral visit from my teenage years, I still wonder about the son I never had the opportunity to meet. What does he look like? What does he enjoy? What’s his favorite color? Who does he feel most safe with?

I wonder what his experience of Christian community was like. I wonder whether those around him knew how much their lives would have been enriched by him. And I wonder how many others have remained similarly unseen within our churches.

And so, my hope is not simply that Chinese churches will become more accommodating and welcoming towards people with disabilities. My hope is that we will rediscover something of the gospel through their presence and participation.

So, there are practical questions worth asking. Are our gatherings accessible? Do our ministries accommodate different ways of communicating, learning, and participating? Are people with disabilities and their families included in conversations about church life? Are we prepared to slow down and listen to their experiences?

But of course, meaningful change must also begin in prayer. We can pray for people with disabilities and their families, particularly those who experience isolation, exhaustion, or stigma. We can pray that churches would become communities where people need not conceal their vulnerabilities in order to belong.

We can pray for pastors and Christian leaders to grow in theological understanding, and for people with disabilities to have meaningful opportunities to shape the life and witness of their churches.

And perhaps most importantly, we can pray together with people with disabilities as fellow members of Christ’s body, asking God to teach us what it truly means to need one another.

The Chinese church has much to offer the global Christian community through its rich traditions of relationality and shared responsibility. My hope and prayer is that, as these strengths are deepened by the gospel, our churches might become places where no member is regarded as unnecessary, no family is left to struggle alone, no person must earn the right to belong, and the names of those like the young man I mentioned earlier would be known and treasured. And perhaps, as we learn to belong to one another more faithfully, the world will catch a clearer glimpse of the grace we proclaim.

Elliot Ku headshot

Elliot Ku is a lecturer in Practical Theology and Christian Thought at Sydney Missionary and Bible College and lead pastor of The Well Church in Sydney. A Malaysian-born Chinese, he has lived in Australia for over…